Obligatory
"Sorry I haven't done a proper post in forever" explanation ahead.
Long, boring story short: school and work are the greedy friends who monopolize
my time and refuse to share me with anyone else. So don't blame me, blame them.
Unsurprisingly, most of what I think about revolves around my classes. We just
finished Oedipus Rex in AP Literature and as if I didn't have enough homework
and lack of sleep to brighten my day, the play's resolution is heartbreaking.
Another long story short: there is one less pair of eyes by the end of the
play.
This
got me thinking; I've never read a Young Adult novel with a tragic ending. I
didn't find the Hunger Games trilogy ending all that happy and The Fault in Our
Stars wasn't full of kittens and rainbows, but did they give me the same
rip-out-my-heart-so-I-can-just-die-already feeling that Oedipus Rex or the
Great Gatsby did. If Young Adult novels are bitter at all, they are bitter
sweet. So my question is, would a completely tragic ending in a book written
for teenagers work?
A lot
of YA deals in escapism, allowing teenagers to forget about the stress of the
real world for a few chapters. The stories may have fear, pain, and danger, but
they don't launch the reader into a world more hopeless than their own. That's
not to make YA literature sound shallow. It deals with unbelievably hard
topics, from eating disorders to death and suicide. Only the characters are
meant to serve as inspiration, to show that these problems can be overcome. But
would a book with no light at the end of the tunnel still be a good read? Would
it sell? I don't know the answer, but if anyone has any examples of this, feel
free to comment.
P.S. I'm now on Twitter @EmmaSchmidtke
No comments:
Post a Comment